Description: ------------ When I create new instance of QuickForm, setting $trackSubmit=true (I need this because I have four forms into a single PHP file), the Tableless renderer misses the <fieldset> open tag, generating an invalid XHTML, like below: <form action="test.php" method="post" id="form"> <input name="_qf__form" type="hidden" value="" /> </fieldset> (...) This needs to be corrected including the open tag (if remove fieldset tag the XHTML doesn't be compliance with XHTML 1.1 specification *), but with fieldset an empty frame will be draw, that it is not desired. My sugestion is to use the inline CSS style "visibility:hidden", like example below: <form action="test.php" method="post" id="form"> <fieldset style="visibility:hidden"> <input name="_qf__form" type="hidden" value="" /> </fieldset> (...) Thanks for your attention. * document type does not allow element "input" here; missing one of "ins", "del", "h1", "h2", "h3", "h4", "h5", "h6", "p", "div", "address", "fieldset" start-tag. (by www.w3c.org). Test script: --------------- $form = new HTML_QuickForm('form', 'post', 'test.php', null, null, true); $form->addElement('text', 'test', 'Test:'); $renderer =& new HTML_QuickForm_Renderer_Tableless(); $form->accept($renderer); echo $renderer->toHtml(); Expected result: ---------------- <form action="test.php" method="post" id="form"> <fieldset style="visibility:hidden"> <input name="_qf__form" type="hidden" value="" /> </fieldset> (...) Actual result: -------------- <form action="test.php" method="post" id="form"> <input name="_qf__form" type="hidden" value="" /> </fieldset> (...)

Dear Mark, First, congratulations for this excelent package and thanks for your attention. 1. Sorry, my program is biggest, and the error really don't occur with this "small" example that I send. I do more tests and this can reproduce the bug: $form1 = new HTML_QuickForm('form1', 'post', 'test.php', null, null, true); $form1->removeAttribute('name'); $form1->addElement('header', null, 'Test'); $form1->addElement('text', 'Test1', 'Test: '); $form2 = new HTML_QuickForm('form2', 'post', 'test.php', null, null, true); $form2->removeAttribute('name'); $form2->addElement('header', null, 'Test'); $form2->addElement('text', 'Test2', 'Test: '); $form3 = new HTML_QuickForm('form3', 'post', 'test.php', null, null, true); $form3->removeAttribute('name'); $form3->addElement('header', null, 'Test'); $form3->addElement('text', 'Test3', 'Test: '); $renderer =& new HTML_QuickForm_Renderer_Tableless(); $form1->accept($renderer); echo ($renderer->toHtml()); $form2->accept($renderer); echo ($renderer->toHtml()); $form3->accept($renderer); echo ($renderer->toHtml()); If helps, I noticed that the error only occurs when: 1. There are 2 or more forms (note in the example above that the error only occur with "form2" and "form3"); 2. The error don't occur when I removed the lines $formX->addElement('header', null, 'Test'); 2. I consider the W3C validator as reference. If you paste the html below, generated (and corrected) by script above, you will see the "container" requirement. I don't check the DTD my self, but if validator says...

Test

Test:

Test

Test:

Test

Test:

<br /> </fieldset> </form> </body> </html> Regards, Daniel Maglione